Should I Repair or Replace My Tudor Black Bay 58?

Use our smart calculator to analyze whether it's worth fixing your Tudor Black Bay 58 or buying a new one.

Tudor Black Bay 58 Overview

Release Year

2023

Average Price (New)

$3700

Typical Repair Cost

$450

Expected Lifespan

40.0 years

Repairability Score

8/10

★★★★★★★★★★

🌍Environmental Impact

CO₂ saved by repairing: 259kg

E-waste reduced: 0.74kg

Common Issues & Repair Costs

Service overhaul

common
~$4503-4 weeks

Bezel insert

occasional
~$2001 week

Crown tube

occasional
~$1501 week

Bracelet refinish

common
~$2501 week

Smart Calculator

Fill in the details below to get your recommendation

$

💡What you originally paid for this item

$

💡Cost to buy a similar new item today

$

💡Get quotes from repair shops for accuracy

💡How long have you owned this item?

⭐Current Condition

Tudor Black Bay 58 Repair vs Replace Guide

The Tudor Black Bay 58, released in 2023, has become a popular choice in the category. With an average lifespan of 40.0 years and a repairability score of 8/10, understanding when to repair versus replace this device is crucial for making smart financial decisions.

When to Repair Your Tudor Black Bay 58

  • The device is less than 20 years old
  • Repair costs are under $1850 (50% of replacement value)
  • The issue is one of the common, easily fixable problems listed above
  • You're satisfied with the device's performance and features

When to Replace Your Tudor Black Bay 58

  • Multiple components are failing simultaneously
  • The device is approaching or exceeding 40 years old
  • Repair costs exceed $2590 (70% of replacement value)
  • Newer models offer significant improvements in efficiency or features

Environmental Considerations

Choosing to repair your Tudor Black Bay 58 instead of replacing it can save approximately 259kg of CO₂ emissions and prevent 0.74kg of electronic waste from entering landfills. These environmental benefits, combined with potential cost savings, make repair an attractive option when feasible.